Skip to main content

Sharon McLaughlin MD

Woman physician in a white coat pausing in a bright hospital hallway with her hand on her chest, taking a calm breath.

Fawning vs. People-Pleasing: What’s the Difference (and Why It Matters for Women Physicians)

workbooks for women physicians and workshop-for-women-physicians.jpg instead of workshop-Invitation-.jpg Communication coaching for women physicians Sharon Mclaughlin MD monthly workshops

Affiliate disclosure: some links on this site are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Fawning vs. People-Pleasing

You said yes to covering the extra call shift. You said yes to the committee nobody else wanted. You smiled through the meeting where a colleague took credit for your idea, and then you apologized to him for “not being clearer.” If you have ever wondered whether you are just a people-pleaser or whether something deeper is going on, you are asking the right question. Understanding fawning vs people pleasing is one of the most useful distinctions a woman physician can learn, because the two look almost identical from the outside and require very different fixes on the inside.

The word “fawning” has exploded across social media and podcasts over the past few years. Yet most of the conversation is driven by a small number of voices, and the term often gets used as a trendy synonym for “being nice.” That confusion matters. If you treat a survival response like a bad habit, you will keep failing at the scripts, the boundary workbooks, and the “just say no” advice, and you will blame yourself for it.

In this article, I will explain plainly what each term means, how to tell them apart, why women in medicine are especially prone to both, and what to do next depending on which one you recognize in yourself. I am a physician and a leadership coach, not your therapist, so I will also be clear about when a coach is the right support and when a trauma-informed clinician is.

What Is People-Pleasing?

People-pleasing is a pattern of putting other people’s approval, comfort, or convenience ahead of your own needs, usually to avoid conflict or to be liked. It is common, it is learned, and it is mostly conscious. If someone asked you afterward why you agreed, you could usually tell them: “I didn’t want to seem difficult,” or “It was easier than arguing.”

Psychologists have studied a close cousin of people-pleasing for decades under the name sociotropy, a personality style marked by a strong need for acceptance and a fear of disapproval. Aaron Beck first described it in the 1980s as a personality style that can leave people more vulnerable to depression when important relationships feel threatened (Beck, 1983). In other words, the habit has real costs even when it is not rooted in trauma.

Psychotherapist Terri Cole, author of Boundary Boss, describes the trap well. In a 2025 interview she explained that what feels like generosity can actually be an effort to manage someone else’s reaction or sidestep conflict, a “peace at any cost” mindset that eventually breeds resentment (Cole, 2025). Cole has also noted a trend in her own practice of high-achieving professional women who struggle with exactly this.

Here are some hallmarks of ordinary people-pleasing:

  • You agree to requests because saying no feels awkward, not dangerous.
  • You feel a twinge of guilt or discomfort when you disappoint someone, but it passes.
  • You can choose differently when the stakes are high enough. You can say no to a hospital administrator when patient safety is on the line.
  • Practice helps. Boundary scripts, rehearsal, and accountability actually change the behavior over time.

People-pleasing is a habit. Habits respond to awareness, skills, and repetition. That is good news, because it means a clear plan and a few well-practiced scripts can genuinely change your day.

What Is Fawning?

Fawning is a trauma response. Psychotherapist Pete Walker named it in the early 2000s and popularized it in his 2013 book Complex PTSD: From Surviving to Thriving. He described it as a fourth “F” alongside the familiar fight, flight, and freeze responses (Walker, 2003; Walker, 2013).

In Walker’s model, fawning develops when a child faces threat from the very people they depend on. Fighting back or running away is not an option when the danger is your parent. So the child learns to stay safe by becoming agreeable, helpful, and attuned to every shift in the adult’s mood. Walker emphasized that the fawn response is a survival mechanism, not a character flaw.

The key difference is this: fawning is not a choice in the moment. It is an automatic nervous-system reaction to perceived threat. Clinical psychologist Ingrid Clayton, whose 2025 book Fawning has become the most visible popular treatment of the topic, draws the line the same way. In her framing, people-pleasing is more intentional and strategic, while fawning is a survival response rooted in long-standing powerlessness (Clayton, 2025; Psychology Today, 2025).

Researchers are beginning to study the biology. In 2023, a team including polyvagal theorist Stephen Porges proposed the term appeasement to describe a reflexive survival strategy in which a person calms a threatening individual to reduce the risk of harm (Bailey et al., 2023). The empirical research on fawning specifically is still young, and that is worth saying honestly. But the clinical observation is consistent: some people placate under threat in a way that bypasses conscious choice.

Common signs of fawning include:

  • Apologizing to people who have hurt you.
  • Losing track of what you actually think or want, especially around certain people.
  • Hypervigilance: constantly scanning faces, tone, and email phrasing for signs of displeasure.
  • Taking blame automatically, even when the facts point elsewhere.
  • Feeling physical panic (racing heart, tight chest, blankness) at the thought of someone being upset with you.
  • Drawing closer to a person or workplace that hurts you instead of pulling away.

Fawning vs People Pleasing: The Key Differences

The clearest way to understand fawning vs people pleasing is to compare what happens inside you, not just what you do. The outward behavior can be identical: you say yes, you smooth things over, you stay late. The engine underneath is different.

QuestionOrdinary people-pleasingFawning
Where it comes fromLearned habits, social conditioning, wanting approvalSurvival adaptation, often from childhood environments that felt unsafe
Level of choiceMostly conscious; you know you’re doing itAutomatic; often you only notice afterward
What it protects you fromAwkwardness, disapproval, conflictPerceived danger, rejection that feels like a threat to survival
What your body doesMild discomfort, guiltRacing heart, freezing, going blank, intense dread
Your sense of selfYou know what you want but set it asideYou may genuinely not know what you want in the moment
What happens when someone is upsetUncomfortable, but you can tolerate itFeels urgent and unbearable; you must fix it now
Who triggers itMost people, fairly evenlyEspecially people with power or unpredictable moods
What helpsSkills, scripts, practice, accountabilityNervous-system regulation and often trauma-informed therapy, plus skills

A simple self-check: after you say yes when you meant no, ask yourself, “Did I decide that, or did it happen to me?” If you can trace the decision (“I didn’t want to deal with the fallout”), you are probably people-pleasing. If you feel like you watched yourself agree from a distance, with a pounding heart and no access to your own opinion, that may be fawning.

Most women I work with recognize a little of both. That is normal. Patterns are not neat categories, and you don’t need a label to start making changes. The point of the distinction is to choose the right tools.

Why Women Physicians Are Especially Prone to Both

Medicine rewards behaviors that look a lot like fawning. We were trained to anticipate needs before they are spoken, to stay calm when someone powerful is angry, and to absorb blame to keep the team functioning. Many of us went through training under attendings whose moods determined how the day would go. Hypervigilance was not a symptom. It was a job skill.

Add gender expectations, and the pressure compounds. In a well-known set of experiments published in the American Economic Review, Linda Babcock and colleagues found that women were more likely than men to volunteer for tasks with low promotability, such as serving on committees or writing reports. Women were also more likely to be asked and more likely to say yes when asked (Babcock et al., 2017). When participants were sorted into single-gender groups, the gap disappeared. That tells us the pattern is driven largely by expectations, not by women’s personalities.

The consequences show up in our wellbeing data. In the Medscape 2024 Physician Burnout & Depression Report, 56% of women physicians reported burnout compared with 44% of men (Medscape, 2024). The prior year’s report found 63% of women physicians burned out (Medscape, 2023). Only about 15% of burned-out physicians had sought professional help.

Psychologist Ingrid Clayton makes a point that will resonate with many women in medicine: fawning often looks like socially rewarded behavior, such as helpfulness, agreeableness, and selflessness. She argues that many groups, particularly women, have learned to fawn to stay safe, included, or employable (Clayton, 2025). In medicine, those same traits often get you labeled “a team player.” They can also get you burned out.

This is why understanding fawning vs people pleasing matters so much for physicians. A culture that rewards over-accommodation will never tell you it’s a problem. You have to name it yourself.

How Fawning Shows Up at Work

Here are four scenarios I hear about constantly. Notice how the same situation can play out as people-pleasing or as fawning.

1. The schedule request. Your department chair asks you to cover an extra weekend.

  • People-pleasing: You think, “I really don’t want to, but saying no will make things awkward.” You agree, feel resentful, and complain to a friend later.
  • Fawning: Your chest tightens the moment you see his name in your inbox. You reply “Of course, happy to help!” within ninety seconds, before you have even checked your calendar.

2. The credit-stealing colleague. A peer presents your quality-improvement idea as his own.

  • People-pleasing: You decide it isn’t worth the conflict and let it go.
  • Fawning: You congratulate him, offer to help with the slides, and later wonder why you did that.

3. The angry patient family member. Someone raises their voice about wait times.

  • People-pleasing: You over-apologize and promise more than you can deliver.
  • Fawning: You find yourself agreeing that the delays are your fault personally, even though you know they aren’t, and you replay the conversation for days.

4. The business partner. You are launching a practice and your co-founder keeps making unilateral decisions.

  • People-pleasing: You avoid raising it because you don’t want to seem controlling.
  • Fawning: You can’t access your own opinion in the room. You only realize you disagreed after the meeting ends.

For women physician entrepreneurs, this last scenario is especially costly. When you own the business, nobody else is going to protect your boundaries, your pricing, or your time. Left unchecked, fawning becomes a business risk, not just a personal one.

Why Boundary Scripts Don’t Work When You’re Fawning

I teach communication scripts for a living, so let me be honest about their limits. A script is a tool for the thinking part of your brain. Fawning happens when the thinking part goes offline.

When your nervous system perceives a threat, blood flow and attention shift toward survival. You can memorize the perfect sentence, but in the moment your chair walks up to you, the words disappear and “Sure, no problem” comes out. That is not a failure of willpower. It is biology doing what it learned to do.

This is exactly where the distinction between fawning vs people pleasing becomes practical. If you are people-pleasing, a script plus practice usually works. If you are fawning, you need to add a step before the script: getting your body back to a state where you can actually choose.

Therapist Nedra Glover Tawwab, author of Set Boundaries, Find Peace, writes that the hardest part of setting boundaries is accepting that some people won’t like or agree with them, and that setting standards gets easier once you grow beyond pleasing others (Tawwab, 2021). For someone who fawns, that acceptance is not just uncomfortable. It can feel unsafe. That is why the work has to include the body, not just the words.

Action Steps: How to Move From Over-Accommodating to Clear and Firm

Whether you recognize people-pleasing, fawning, or a mix, these steps will help. The first three matter most if you suspect fawning.

  1. Track your yeses for one week. Terri Cole suggests spending 48 hours simply noticing what happens in your interactions before trying to change anything. Keep a note on your phone. For each yes you didn’t mean, write down who asked, what you felt in your body, and whether you decided or reacted.
  2. Name the sensation. When you notice the tight chest or the urge to rush, label it silently: “This is my fawn response.” Research by Matthew Lieberman and colleagues found that putting feelings into words reduced activity in the amygdala, the brain’s alarm center (Lieberman et al., 2007).
  3. Buy yourself time with a standard delay. Fawning thrives on speed. Make it your policy never to agree on the spot. Use one default line, such as “Let me check my schedule and get back to you by end of day.” This gives your nervous system time to settle so your thinking brain can rejoin the conversation.
  4. Regulate before you respond. Try two or three rounds of slow breathing with a longer exhale: a double inhale through the nose, then a long, slow exhale through the mouth. A 2023 randomized study at Stanford found that five minutes a day of this “cyclic sighing” improved mood and lowered respiratory rate more than mindfulness meditation did (Balban et al., 2023).
  5. Decide using your values, not the other person’s face. Before you reply, ask: “If I knew this person would not be upset either way, what would I choose?” That answer is your real preference.
  6. Start with low-stakes noes. Practice declining small things, like a lunch invitation or a non-urgent favor, so your system learns that saying no does not lead to disaster. Small wins build tolerance for bigger ones.
  7. Expect discomfort and let it be there. You will feel guilty the first several times. Guilt is not proof you did something wrong. It is the feeling of breaking an old rule.
  8. Audit your non-promotable tasks. List every committee, report, and “quick favor” you hold. Using the Babcock research as a lens, ask which ones advance your career or business. Give back at least one per quarter.
  9. Get support that matches the pattern. Coaching and skill-building work well for people-pleasing. If fawning runs deep, add a trauma-informed therapist (more on this below).

Communication Scripts for Women Physicians

Once you have bought yourself a pause and settled your body, a short script helps you follow through. Keep these simple. The more words you use, the more you invite negotiation.

When you’re asked to take on extra work:

“Thank you for thinking of me. I’m not able to take that on right now. I’d suggest checking with the scheduling team.”

If they push back: “I understand it puts you in a tough spot. My answer is still no for this one.”

When someone takes credit for your work:

“I’m glad the QI proposal landed well. I’d like to make sure my role in developing it is reflected in the minutes.”

If they push back: “I’m not asking to take anything away from you. I’m asking for accurate attribution.”

When you feel yourself about to fawn in real time:

“I want to give this proper thought. Let me come back to you tomorrow morning.”

This one is your safety line. It works in almost every setting, and it protects you from agreeing before you can think.

When a business partner makes a unilateral decision:

“I’d like us to agree that decisions over a certain dollar amount or affecting our hours get discussed before they’re finalized. Can we set that up this week?”

If they push back: “I understand speed matters. Shared decisions are a condition of this partnership working for me.”

When you notice yourself apologizing for something that isn’t yours:

Replace “I’m so sorry” with “Thank you for your patience” or “I hear that this has been frustrating.” You can be warm without accepting blame.

When to Seek Trauma-Informed Support

Coaching, workbooks, and scripts are powerful for building skills. They are not a substitute for therapy when trauma is driving the pattern. Consider reaching out to a licensed, trauma-informed therapist if:

  • You recognize most of the fawning signs above, especially the physical panic and going blank.
  • You have a history of growing up around anger, unpredictability, or emotional neglect.
  • You keep returning to people or workplaces that hurt you, even when you can see the pattern clearly.
  • Your attempts to set boundaries trigger intense anxiety, shame, or physical symptoms that last for days.

As physicians, we are notoriously bad at getting help for ourselves. The Medscape data showing that only about 15% of burned-out physicians sought professional support should be a wake-up call. If you would refer a patient for this, you deserve the same referral.

Conclusion: Kindness Is a Choice. Fawning Is Not.

The heart of fawning vs people pleasing comes down to one question: Do you have a choice in the moment? People-pleasing is a habit you can change with awareness and practice. Fawning is a survival response that needs your body to feel safe before your words can follow. Neither makes you weak. Both made sense once. Both can change.

You can stay the generous, attuned, collaborative physician you are. The goal is not to stop caring about others. It is to make sure caring about others is something you choose, not something that happens to you.

If you want structured help practicing this, download my free workbook, Reclaiming Your Peace: A Workbook for Women Physicians, at SharonMcLaughlinMD.com/workbook. When you join, you’ll also get weekly inspiration and invitations to my monthly workshops, where we practice these conversations together in a supportive room of women who get it.

References

  1. Babcock, L., Recalde, M. P., Vesterlund, L., & Weingart, L. (2017). Gender differences in accepting and receiving requests for tasks with low promotability. American Economic Review, 107(3), 714–747. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20141734
  2. Bailey, R., Dugard, J., Smith, S. F., & Porges, S. W. (2023). Appeasement: Replacing Stockholm syndrome as a definition of a survival strategy. European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 14(1), 2161038. https://doi.org/10.1080/20008066.2022.2161038
  3. Balban, M. Y., Neri, E., Kogon, M. M., et al. (2023). Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal. Cell Reports Medicine, 4(1), 100895.
  4. Beck, A. T. (1983). Cognitive therapy of depression: New perspectives. In P. J. Clayton & J. E. Barrett (Eds.), Treatment of depression: Old controversies and new approaches. Raven Press.
  5. Clayton, I. (2025). Fawning: Why the need to please makes us lose ourselves—and how to find our way back. G.P. Putnam’s Sons. Publisher page
  6. Cole, T. (2025, February). How to break the people-pleasing cycle and set healthy boundaries [Podcast episode]. The One You Feed. Episode page
  7. Lieberman, M. D., Eisenberger, N. I., Crockett, M. J., Tom, S. M., Pfeifer, J. H., & Way, B. M. (2007). Putting feelings into words: Affect labeling disrupts amygdala activity in response to affective stimuli. Psychological Science, 18(5), 421–428.
  8. Medscape. (2023). Physician Burnout & Depression Report 2023. Summary via Becker’s ASC Review
  9. Medscape. (2024). Physician Burnout & Depression Report 2024. Summary via Chief Healthcare Executive and Health Populi
  10. Psychology Today. (2025, October). How fawning creates distance in adult relationships. Article
  11. Tawwab, N. G. (2021). Set boundaries, find peace: A guide to reclaiming yourself. TarcherPerigee.
  12. Walker, P. (2003). Codependency, trauma and the fawn response. The East Bay Therapist. Article
  13. Walker, P. (2013). Complex PTSD: From surviving to thriving. Azure Coyote Publishing.

Leadership doesn’t have to cost you your peace.

Medical culture rewards hustle and self-sacrifice, but burnout isn’t the price of doing this work. Boundaries, clear communication, and knowing how to say no aren’t weaknesses; they’re leadership skills.

Through practical scripts and real stories built for women physicians and beyond, this space helps you navigate the hard conversations, so you can build a career that feels sustainable, not draining.

Whether you’re recovering from burnout or growing your own business, you’ll find guidance to lead with clarity and stop shrinking to keep the peace.

Share this article-

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn