Skip to main content

Sharon McLaughlin MD

woman negotiating a raise

Women Do Ask: What The Research Reveals About Women and Salary Negotiation

workbooks for women physicians and workshop-for-women-physicians.jpg instead of workshop-Invitation-.jpg Communication coaching for women physicians Sharon Mclaughlin MD monthly workshops

Affiliate disclosure: some links on this site are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Women Do Ask: What The Research Reveals About Women and Salary Negotiation

For decades, the conversation about women and salary negotiation has started from the same assumption: women are paid less because they don’t ask. Fix the woman, the logic goes, and you fix the gap. Teach her to be bolder, practice her “power pose,” send her to one more confidence workshop.

Research from the University of California, Berkeley’s Haas School of Business turns that assumption on its head. Professor Laura Kray and her co-authors found that professional women now report negotiating their pay more often than men. They are not failing to ask. They are being told “no” more often when they do.

If you are a woman physician who has negotiated an employment contract, a partnership track, call pay, or a buy-in, this probably matches your lived experience. You prepared. You asked. And the answer still came back smaller than you expected, or with a comment about your “tone.”

I practiced surgery for about twelve years before moving into administration and health policy. I have sat on both sides of the table. In this article, I’ll walk you through what the new research actually says, why it matters so much in medicine, and, most importantly, what you can do with it. You’ll get evidence, specific scripts, and action steps you can use in your next negotiation, whether you are an employed physician or building your own practice.

Women Don’t Ask: Where the Myth Came From

The phrase “women don’t ask” became famous in 2003, when economist Linda Babcock and writer Sara Laschever published a book by that name. Early lab studies and surveys suggested that men were more likely than women to initiate salary negotiations. The finding was memorable, intuitive, and easy to act on. It launched what Berkeley Haas calls a cottage industry of books and workshops designed to make women better negotiators.

At the time, the data may have been accurate. But data has a shelf life, and beliefs often outlast the evidence behind them.

Here is the problem with the “women don’t ask” frame. It locates the cause of the pay gap inside the woman. If she earns less, she must not have pushed hard enough. That makes the solution personal: more coaching, more courage, more practice. It quietly removes the people making pay decisions from the story.

Kray and her colleagues call this a “legitimizing myth.” It is a belief that makes an unfair system feel fair. If women simply need to ask, then no one has to examine how offers are set, how raises are approved, or how the same request is heard differently depending on who makes it.

As a physician, you already understand this pattern. When a protocol keeps failing, we don’t keep blaming individual patients for poor outcomes. We look at the system. The same logic applies to pay.

A quick timeline of the research

Kray’s team re-examined a 2018 meta-analysis that had concluded women were less likely than men to initiate negotiations. They focused on nine studies published between 1982 and 2015 and added time as a variable. The results changed the picture:

  • In the earlier years, men did report negotiating more often than women.
  • Around 1994, the gender difference appeared to disappear.
  • Beginning around 2007, it reversed, with women reporting negotiating more often than men.

In other words, the advice many of us received in training was already out of date by the time we heard it.

Women Do Ask: What the Berkeley Haas Study Found

The paper, “Now, Women Do Ask: A Call to Update Beliefs about the Gender Pay Gap,” was written by Laura Kray of Berkeley Haas, Jessica Kennedy of Vanderbilt University, and Margaret Lee of Berkeley Haas. It appeared in Academy of Management Discoveries. The researchers used several data sources and experiments. Here are the findings that matter most for women and salary negotiation.

FindingWomenMen
Graduates of a top MBA program (2015–2019) who negotiated their job offer54%44%
Pay right after the MBA, as a share of men’s pay88%100%
Pay 10 years after the MBA, as a share of men’s pay63%100%
Overall pay among 1,900 alumni surveyed in 201922% less—

Women asked more, and heard “no” more

In the 2019 survey of 1,900 MBA alumni, graduates reported their salaries and whether they had ever asked for a raise or promotion. They also reported whether the ask worked and whether they had ever received a raise without asking.

Two things stood out. First, asking works: people who negotiated were more likely to earn more than those who did not. The researchers explicitly encourage everyone to ask. Second, apart from lower pay, the only gender differences were that more women had tried to negotiate and more women had been turned down.

The authors concluded that, because women were more likely to ask, a gap in asking cannot explain the pay gap in this group.

The gap grows as careers advance

Men and women leave an MBA program with nearly identical skills and credentials. Yet the gap widens sharply over the next decade. That pattern should sound familiar to physicians. We finish residency with the same boards and the same training, then watch our paths diverge.

The “fix the women” message can backfire

The team also ran experiments with about 500 college-educated people who had managerial experience. Those who believed more strongly that women’s negotiation habits explained the pay gap were less likely to support salary-history bans. They were also more likely to defend the current system.

In a final experiment, people who read a passage from a negotiation book aimed at women endorsed gender stereotypes more than people who read a gender-neutral negotiation text. Well-meant advice, framed the wrong way, reinforced the very bias it was meant to fight.

Kray’s summary of the takeaway is blunt: it is time to retire the idea that the pay gap exists because women don’t ask.

What this study does and doesn’t tell us

As evidence-based clinicians, we should read the limits too. The core data come from graduates of one elite MBA program and are self-reported. The study does not include physicians. It shows that women ask at least as often as men, and are told no more often. It does not prove exactly why. Other research, which we’ll look at next, helps fill in that “why.”

The Gender Pay Gap in Medicine

If you think medicine is immune to this, the numbers say otherwise. Doximity’s Physician Compensation Report 2026, published in August 2026, found that the physician gender pay gap was 26% in 2025, unchanged from the year before. The report drew on nearly 23,000 surveys from full-time U.S. physicians working at least 40 hours a week.

After adjusting for specialty, location, and years of experience, male physicians earned an average of $122,276 more than female physicians in 2025. Men out-earned women in every specialty included in the report.

Specialty (Doximity 2026 report)Gender pay gap
Thoracic surgery19.7%
Gastroenterology16.6%
Pediatric rheumatology16.1%
Otolaryngology15.4%
Pediatrics15.4%
Pediatric cardiology (smallest gap)8.7%

The gap is not a story about fewer hours. In its prior report, Doximity noted that its analysis controls for hours worked and career stage, along with specialty, work type, employment status, region, and credentials.

What the gap costs over a career

A 2021 study in Health Affairs, led by Christopher Whaley of the RAND Corporation, analyzed data from more than 80,000 full-time U.S. physicians. Over a simulated 40-year career, men earned about $8.31 million and women about $6.26 million, a difference of roughly $2 million.

The gap was largest in surgical specialties, at about $2.5 million. It was $1.6 million in nonsurgical specialties and about $900,000 in primary care. Even emergency medicine, with the smallest gap, showed a difference of more than $620,000. Whaley noted that the gap opens early in a career and rarely closes, and that the study probably understates the true difference.

For women physicians, this is why the first contract matters so much. Every future raise, bonus, and retirement contribution is built on that starting number.

Why the Haas findings matter for physicians

Put the two bodies of research side by side. Women physicians have highly comparable training. Many of us were coached for years to “just ask.” And still the gap holds at about 26%.

The Haas study gives us a better hypothesis. The issue for women and salary negotiation may not be how often we ask. It may be how the ask is received and how often it is granted. That shifts the conversation from “What’s wrong with her approach?” to “What’s happening on the other side of the table?”

Negotiation Backlash: Why Evaluators Penalize the Ask

The Haas study isn’t the only research pointing at the evaluator. Several well-designed studies, published years apart, tell a consistent story.

Women ask as often, but get less often

In 2018, economists Benjamin Artz, Amanda Goodall, and Andrew Oswald published “Do Women Ask?” in the journal Industrial Relations. They used matched employer-employee data from the 2013–2014 Australian Workplace Relations Survey. It was the first study able to ask workers directly about their asking behavior in this kind of data set.

They found that men and women asked for raises and promotions equally often. But women who asked got a raise 15% of the time, compared with 20% for men. They also tested a common explanation, that women hold back to protect relationships at work. The same share of men and women, 14%, said they had avoided asking for that reason.

That is two independent data sets, on two continents, a few years apart, reaching the same conclusion: women ask, and women don’t get.

Sometimes it does hurt to ask

Why would the same request land differently? Harvard’s Hannah Riley Bowles, with Linda Babcock and Lei Lai, ran four experiments that remain some of the most cited in this field. Participants evaluated job candidates who either accepted an offer or asked for higher pay.

Evaluators penalized women more than men for negotiating. In the videotaped experiment, male evaluators penalized women who negotiated more than men who did, while female evaluators penalized all candidates who negotiated. The researchers concluded that women’s hesitancy to negotiate in some settings may be a reasonable response to how they are treated, not a personal deficit.

The mechanism has a name: prescriptive gender stereotypes. These are beliefs about how women should behave, such as being warm, modest, and focused on others. When a woman advocates for herself, she can be seen as violating those expectations. The penalty shows up as being rated less likable or someone people would prefer not to work with.

Advocating for others feels different

Research by Emily Amanatullah and Michael Morris found that women tend to negotiate more effectively on behalf of others than for themselves, partly because of the anticipated social backlash for self-advocacy. Most women physicians recognize this instantly. We will fight hard for a patient’s prior authorization or a resident’s schedule. Advocating for our own compensation feels different.

This is not about blaming evaluators either

Most people who penalize women for asking don’t intend to. These are often unconscious reactions. But unconscious doesn’t mean unchangeable. Bias in compensation can be measured, tracked, and designed out, which is where leaders come in later in this article.

In the meantime, you still have negotiations in front of you. So let’s turn to what actually works.

Salary Negotiation Scripts for Women Physicians

Here’s the good news. If the challenge is how the ask is received, then how you frame the ask matters, and it is something you can practice. This is not about shrinking yourself or sounding “nicer.” It’s about using language that makes your request easy for the other person to say yes to.

The research-backed framework: relational accounts

In a 2013 study in Psychology of Women Quarterly, Bowles and Babcock tested ways for women to negotiate without paying a social penalty. Simply sounding warm wasn’t enough. Simply justifying the request wasn’t enough either. What worked was combining both into a “relational account.”

A relational account explains why your request is legitimate and shows that you care about the relationship and the organization. In their experiments, this approach improved both the pay outcome and how women were perceived. It had no comparable effect for men, which tells you this is a tool for navigating a biased environment, not a sign that women are doing it wrong.

A strong relational account has three parts:

  1. Legitimacy: objective data, such as market benchmarks, wRVUs, quality metrics, or a competing offer.
  2. Shared goals: how the request connects to what the organization or practice wants.
  3. Partnership: language that invites problem-solving rather than a standoff.

Script 1: Countering an initial employment offer

Instead of: “I was hoping for more money.”

Try: “I’m excited about joining the group, and I want this to be a long-term fit for both of us. I’ve reviewed the current MGMA and Doximity benchmarks for my specialty in this region, and this offer is below the median for my experience level. Given the volume you’ve projected for this position, I’d like to discuss a base of [specific number]. What flexibility do you have to get us there?”

Why it works: it leads with commitment, anchors to external data, ties the number to their projected volume, and ends with an open question.

Script 2: Asking for a raise as an employed physician

“Over the last 12 months, my panel grew by [X] patients and my wRVUs exceeded target by [Y]%. I’ve also taken on [committee or teaching role]. I’d like to make sure my compensation reflects that contribution so I can keep investing in this department long-term. Can we review my compensation against current benchmarks before the next contract cycle?”

Script 3: When your manager suggested you ask

Bowles and Babcock found that referencing a supervisor’s encouragement was one effective relational account. If someone above you has acknowledged your value, use it.

“When we met in March, Dr. [Name] mentioned I should raise compensation during this review. I appreciated that, and I’d like to follow up on it today.”

Script 4: Responding to a “no”

The Haas data says you’re more likely to hear no. Plan for it in advance so it doesn’t end the conversation.

“I understand the budget is tight this cycle. Help me understand what would need to be true for this to change. Could we agree on specific metrics and revisit in six months? I’d also like to talk about non-salary items: protected admin time, CME funds, a signing bonus, or a call-schedule adjustment.”

Then follow up in writing: “Thank you for meeting today. To confirm, we agreed to revisit my compensation on [date], based on [metrics].”

Script 5: Negotiating as a practice owner

If you’ve left employed medicine to build your own practice, you are now negotiating with payers, vendors, landlords, and hospital partners. Women and salary negotiation research applies here too, because the person across the table may hold the same unconscious expectations.

“We’d like to continue partnering with your network. Our patient satisfaction scores are in the top decile and our no-show rate is below the regional average, which lowers your total cost of care. For that reason, we’re requesting a rate adjustment to [number] for these CPT codes. Can we schedule time to review the data together?”

Script 6: Naming the pattern, carefully

Sometimes data reveals a real gap. You can raise it without making an accusation.

“I recently learned that compensation for physicians in comparable roles here may differ by gender. I’m sure that isn’t intentional, and I’d appreciate your help understanding how compensation is determined so we can make sure it’s consistent.”

When the stakes are high, such as a confirmed pay disparity, consider consulting an employment attorney before this conversation.

Physician Contract Negotiation: Action Steps

Research is only useful if it changes what you do on Monday. Here is a step-by-step plan you can start this week.

  1. Keep asking. The Haas data confirms that people who negotiate earn more than people who don’t. Being told no more often is a reason to ask strategically, not a reason to stop.
  2. Get your numbers before every conversation. Pull benchmarks from at least two sources, such as MGMA, Doximity, or your specialty society. Know the 25th, 50th, and 75th percentiles for your specialty, region, and years in practice.
  3. Track your own data all year. Keep a simple running file of wRVUs, panel size, quality scores, patient satisfaction, committee work, teaching, and leadership roles. Don’t rebuild it from memory the week before a review.
  4. Write your relational account in advance. Draft three sentences: why the request is legitimate, how it serves shared goals, and an open question that invites partnership.
  5. Name your walk-away point. Decide before the meeting what number or package you would accept, and what you would do if you can’t get there.
  6. Rehearse out loud, ideally on video. Practice with a colleague or coach who will push back. Watch for hedging words such as “just,” “sort of,” and “I was wondering if maybe.”
  7. Prepare your response to “no.” Have a follow-up question, a non-salary alternative, and a date to revisit ready to go.
  8. Negotiate the whole package. Base salary is only one lever. Consider signing bonus, productivity model, call pay, protected admin time, CME, relocation, partnership track, and non-compete terms.
  9. Get it in writing. Send a short email after every compensation conversation summarizing what was agreed and the next date.
  10. Have your contract reviewed. A physician-focused contract attorney can spot terms that cost far more than any salary difference.
  11. Use your network. Ask trusted colleagues what they were offered and what they negotiated. Salary transparency among peers is one of the fastest ways to discover a gap.
  12. Advocate for someone else, too. Mentor a resident or junior colleague through her first contract. You’ll sharpen your own skills, and you’ll help change the pattern for the next generation.

A sample one-week prep plan

  • Day 1: Pull benchmark data from two sources
  • Day 2: Update your personal performance file
  • Day 3: Write your relational account and target number
  • Day 4: Decide your walk-away point and non-salary priorities
  • Day 5: Rehearse with a colleague or coach, including a “no”
  • Day 6: Refine your script and prepare your follow-up email
  • Day 7: Rest. Walk in calm and prepared.

Pay Equity in Healthcare: Fixing the Evaluator Side

Many women in our community are now the ones making offers. You might be a department chair, a medical director, or a practice owner hiring your first associate. That means the research on women and salary negotiation is also about you, sitting on the other side of the table.

Here’s how to make sure your own decisions don’t reproduce the gap.

Audit the asks, not just the offers

Kray has recommended that organizations run hiring audits. Track the offers made to candidates by gender and race, what each candidate asked for, and how the organization responded. Without that data, it’s impossible to see whether you say yes more often to one group than another.

How to start: create a simple spreadsheet for every hire and every raise request. Record the initial offer, the counter, the final outcome, and the decision-maker. Review it every six months.

Use transparent, structured compensation

The Health Affairs authors pointed to salary transparency, equal-pay laws, and systematic tracking of gender differences in pay as ways to narrow physician income gaps. In practice, that can look like:

  • Published salary bands for each role and experience level
  • A written formula for productivity and quality bonuses
  • The same starting offer for candidates with the same credentials, regardless of whether they negotiate
  • A second reviewer for any compensation decision outside the band

Check your own reaction

When a woman counters your offer, notice your first internal response. Does it feel “aggressive” or “demanding” when the same words from a man would feel “confident”? A useful habit is the flip test: imagine the identical request coming from a male colleague and ask whether your answer would change.

Reward the ask

Tell candidates that you expect them to negotiate. Say it out loud and put it in writing. When negotiation is explicitly invited, the social risk of asking drops for everyone.

Don’t send women to fix themselves

The Haas experiments showed that negotiation advice framed as “for women” can strengthen stereotypes. If you run training, make negotiation education gender-neutral and pair it with structural changes. Training without system change keeps the burden on the people who are already being told no.

Conclusion: You Were Never the Problem

For twenty years, women have been told that the pay gap is something we could close by trying harder. The evidence now says something different. Women ask. In some groups, we ask more often than men. What we face is a higher rate of “no.”

That doesn’t mean negotiation skills are useless. Asking still pays off, and framing still matters. It means the goal of women and salary negotiation training should shift. The aim isn’t to fix ourselves. It’s to walk in with data, a clear relational account, a plan for “no,” and the confidence that comes from knowing the research is on our side. And for those of us who now lead, it’s to make sure our own organizations stop penalizing the ask.

If you’d like to practice these scripts with other women physicians who understand exactly what you’re facing, join us in the Female Physicians Entrepreneurs Facebook group and at our monthly workshop. Bring your next negotiation, and let’s prepare for it together.

Your next step: Pick one negotiation coming up in the next 90 days. Write your three-sentence relational account today.

References

  1. Artz, B., Goodall, A. H., & Oswald, A. J. (2018). Do women ask? Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society, 57(4), 611–636. https://doi.org/10.1111/irel.12214
  2. Bowles, H. R., & Babcock, L. (2013). How can women escape the compensation negotiation dilemma? Relational accounts are one answer. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 37(1), 80–96. Summary
  3. Bowles, H. R., Babcock, L., & Lai, L. (2007). Social incentives for gender differences in the propensity to initiate negotiations: Sometimes it does hurt to ask. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 103(1), 84–103. Harvard DASH
  4. Babcock, L., & Laschever, S. (2003). Women Don’t Ask: Negotiation and the Gender Divide. Princeton University Press.
  5. Becker’s ASC Review. (2026). The physician gender pay gap hasn’t budged: 8 things to know (Doximity Physician Compensation Report 2026). Link
  6. Counts, L. (2023, August 22). New research shatters outdated pay-gap myth that women don’t negotiate. Haas News, UC Berkeley. Link
  7. Evert, C. (2023, August 25). “Women do ask”: Haas professor dispels gender wage gap myths. The Daily Californian. Link
  8. Hannon, K. (2023, November 18). Women do ask for more money — but get turned down more often, study shows. Yahoo Finance. Link
  9. Kray, L. J., Kennedy, J. A., & Lee, M. (2023). Now, women do ask: A call to update beliefs about the gender pay gap. Academy of Management Discoveries. https://doi.org/10.5465/amd.2022.0021
  10. The Hospitalist. (2025). Physician compensation gains small, gaps large (Doximity Physician Compensation Report 2025). Link
  11. Whaley, C. M., Koo, T., Arora, V. M., et al. (2021). Female physicians earn an estimated $2 million less than male physicians over a simulated 40-year career. Health Affairs, 40(12). Link
  12. Amanatullah, E. T., & Morris, M. W. (2010). Negotiating gender roles: Gender differences in assertive negotiating are mediated by women’s fear of backlash and attenuated when negotiating on behalf of others. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 98(2), 256–267.

Leadership doesn’t have to cost you your peace.

Medical culture rewards hustle and self-sacrifice, but burnout isn’t the price of doing this work. Boundaries, clear communication, and knowing how to say no aren’t weaknesses; they’re leadership skills.

Through practical scripts and real stories built for women physicians and beyond, this space helps you navigate the hard conversations, so you can build a career that feels sustainable, not draining.

Whether you’re recovering from burnout or growing your own business, you’ll find guidance to lead with clarity and stop shrinking to keep the peace.

Share this article-

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn